Grow Up or Die

It had to happen. I just had to go see Bill Maher’s movie, Religulous. And the chilling words from the closing scene “Grow up or die” is still echoing  in my mind. It’s meant to sound dramatic and that it certainly does, but how true is it?

Overall, I have to admit that I quite enjoyed the film. It’s generally very funny, although this could be attributed to skillful editing for the most part. Maher may have intended the film to come across as a personal journey in disbelief, but it does become quite “preachy” in parts. I should know, because I also indulged in a similar form of extreme Atheism in the past. Did the film strike a chord with the audience? Well, the approximately five other people who were at the screening were apparently stunned into silence, because I could clearly hear only myself laughing out loud, throughout the film. No doubt, they were believers to some degree, if not outright religionists. I’m not sure what to make of their silence, but it could probably mean one of two things. Either they were genuinely shocked at what they saw and were silently contemplating the apparent mirror image of their own behaviour, or they were disgusted into silence which only means that their attitude to atheism will only harden.

Just prior to exclaiming that we must “grow up or die,” Maher made another blatantly extremist comment while standing at the infamous Megiddo site in Israel, “Religion must die so man can live.” Sounds rather clever, but I don’t believe this will go down all that well with the religious community either. Maher also exhorts all atheists to publicly take a stand against religiosity in a manner which can only be described as proselytizing. I’ve exposed this type of behaviour as rather unethical, previously on this blog. I’m now of the opinion that religion should be allowed to run its course, with only a mild form of dissonance from Atheists in the form of teaching and encouraging rational thinking. Better that it dies a natural death while mankind slowly grows up.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Grow Up or Die

  1. Haven’t seen this yet, but I did have some inkling to see it. I thought the movie “Dogma” was incredibly clever and loved it for it’s outrageous treatment of religious subjects, as well as its commentary on contemporary religion.

    Did you find any attempt to be clever with Maher? Or was it just an in-your-face religion bash?

    • I haven’t seen Dogma yet, but from what you say, it sounds like another mockumentary. I don’t think Maher set out to be “clever.” I think he knew full well that his subjects would “incriminate” themselves, and with a little “clever” editing, it certainly did damn them. Ridicule is great when comics use it once off, for a stage performance or even in a film like this. But as a sustained tool to change irrational thinking, it is no good.

  2. Yeah, Dogma isn’t quite a mockumentary. It actually has a plot to follow, but it does throw in some nice commentary. Chris Rock plays the little known 13th apostle, Rufus. Jay and Silent Bob are prominent figures. George Carlin is a Catholic Bishop. I do agree that the in your face ridicule doesn’t really change people’s minds. It either fires them up if they’re on your side, or it just pisses people off and disgusts them even more with you…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s